Mario & Luigi: Brothership REVIEW

This site contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission on purchases made through these links.

In the vast ocean of role-playing games, the Mario & Luigi series has always charted a unique course, blending whimsical storytelling with engaging mechanics. After nearly a decade adrift, the franchise returns with "Mario & Luigi: Brothership," inviting players to embark on a high-seas adventure that promises both nostalgia and novelty.

Game Information

Developer: Acquire
Publisher: Nintendo
Release Date: 7 November 2024
Platforms: Nintendo Switch

Setting Sail: The Story

"Mario & Luigi: Brothership" transports our beloved plumbers to the fractured world of Concordia, a once-unified land now splintered into floating islands following the destruction of the sacred Uni-Tree. Aboard the aptly named Shipshape Island—a vessel that's part ship, part island—Mario and Luigi, alongside new companions like Connie and Snoutlet, set out to reconnect these islands and restore harmony. The narrative weaves themes of unity and connection, resonating with the series' hallmark charm.

Gameplay: Navigating Familiar Waters with New Currents

At its core, "Brothership" retains the turn-based combat and exploration that fans cherish. Each brother is assigned a specific button, allowing for coordinated attacks and defences that require precise timing. The introduction of "Bros. Moves" and "Bros. Attacks" adds layers of strategy, encouraging players to master combined abilities for maximum impact.

A standout addition is the "Battle Plug" system, which grants Mario and Luigi special effects during battles. These plugs can automate healing, enhance attacks, or provide defensive buffs, adding a strategic depth that keeps encounters engaging. However, some critics have noted that while these mechanics are innovative, they can occasionally disrupt the game's pacing.

Exploration is enriched by "Luigi Logic," moments where Luigi's insights lead to puzzle-solving opportunities. These instances not only highlight Luigi's character but also introduce creative challenges that break the monotony of combat. The game's world is diverse, with each island offering unique themes and inhabitants, from the dance-centric Twistee Island to the contrasting climates of Heatfreeze Island.

Latest Reviews


Visuals and Performance: A Mixed Bag

Visually, "Brothership" embraces a vibrant, anime-inspired art style that breathes life into its characters and settings. The expressive animations, especially during combat, add a layer of personality that enhances the storytelling. However, the game isn't without its technical hiccups. Some players have reported performance issues, particularly frame rate drops in busier areas or during complex animations. These stutters, while not game-breaking, can detract from the overall experience.

Humour and Writing: A Double-Edged Sword

Humour has always been a cornerstone of the Mario & Luigi series, and "Brothership" continues this tradition with a script rich in puns and light-hearted banter. While many jokes land well, eliciting genuine laughter, others may feel overdone or overly simplistic, potentially leading to a sense of repetitiveness. The game's writing aims to be accessible to all ages, which, while commendable, might not resonate with players seeking more nuanced humour.

Length and Replayability: A Voyage of Considerable Length

Clocking in at approximately 35 to 45 hours, "Brothership" offers a substantial journey filled with main quests, side missions, and mini-games. The game's pacing is generally well-managed, with new mechanics and challenges introduced at intervals to maintain player interest. However, some critics have pointed out that certain segments can feel drawn out, with fetch quests and repetitive tasks potentially leading to fatigue.

Conclusion: A Worthy Expedition with Some Rough Seas

"Mario & Luigi: Brothership" successfully navigates the delicate balance between honouring its roots and introducing fresh elements. Its engaging combat, charming visuals, and heartfelt narrative make it a commendable addition to the series. However, technical issues and occasional pacing problems prevent it from reaching its full potential. For fans of the franchise and newcomers alike, it offers a delightful, if imperfect, adventure on the high seas.

Pros

  • Engaging and strategic combat system
  • Charming art style with expressive animations
  • Heartfelt narrative exploring themes of unity

Cons

  • Performance issues, including frame rate drops
  • Occasional pacing problems with repetitive tasks
  • Humour may not resonate with all players
7.5

Overall Score

Suggested Reading

This site contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission on purchases made through these links.

LATEST Indie Reviews


Glitch out on our socials…